Puzzle Case: Draining Fistula Associated with a Vital Pulp

Terry Pannkuk, DDS, MScD Instructional, Clinical Endodontic Technique Instruction, Diagnosis

Join The Discussion

12 comments

Commenting Guidelines Please make scholarly cited references or expert opinions suitable for publication. The comments can either be "pro" or "con" with references to the treatment philosophy. We encourage objectivity and detailed demonstration of knowledge/literature.
James Tinnin commented 8 years ago.

Retained root primary tooth with necrotic pulp

Terrell Pannkuk commented 8 years ago.

Interesting idea that I didn't think of! Bicuspids come in to replace the deciduous molars do you think a primary molar root could have drifted that far mesially? I'll add that idea to my differential diagnosis. Thanks Jim!

Terrell Pannkuk commented 8 years ago.

I'll add the remaining data I have on this case by the end of the day giving people a chance to guess what's going on. I'm not sure I really have the answer to this puzzle and it should generate some excellent comments!

Ashley Mark commented 8 years ago.

Hi Terry, Interesting case. Perplexing. Where do you find these things?! I initially thought this was perio based on your sensitivity tests, and the location of the fistula. Basic question - were you able to track the fistula? 2 questions: Have you thought of getting an OMF radiologist to read the scan to see what they think? I was also thinking that another possible ddx could be an enostosis - however - in the sagittal view, it does appear to have some sort of PDL like structure. Thanks for posting. A

Terrell Pannkuk commented 8 years ago.

Answers to your questions: 1. I could not get a gutta percha cone to go into the sinus tract it might have been healing, so no radiograph of the tracing 2. I have thought of getting and OMF radiologist to read the scan but figured it was a bit premature at this point wanting to wait and see if the fistula heals and comes back. If it comes back then that might be the next step, although I'm a bit more personally inclined to simply flap and debride which might definitively eliminate the etiology even though we me never find out what it really was. A biopsy submission would be possible with the flap procedure which would be very simple to perform. The enostosis idea is another good intellectual stab at what this might be. I liked Tinnin's retained primary root idea except it just happened to be the wrong area! It's fun to try and figure these out. Once in a while amidst our constant daily routine of endo after endo we get thrown a few curve balls. My point in presenting this one is to show that not every case presentation has an obvious answer. Quite frankly I still don't know what the Hell this is and won't pretend that I do. It's food for thought. Maybe some clever person will figure it out. If the sinus tract heals and never comes back, we'll never have a definitive answer to this puzzle. That's a good thing for the patient, but ironically not a good thing for our intellectual curiosity and educational growth. I'll keep you posted if I get more information with an update. Thanks again for your engagement and participation on the PDL site. I appreciate your support Ashley!

Terrell Pannkuk commented 8 years ago.

Answers to your questions: 1. I could not get a gutta percha cone to go into the sinus tract it might have been healing, so no radiograph of the tracing 2. I have thought of getting and OMF radiologist to read the scan but figured it was a bit premature at this point wanting to wait and see if the fistula heals and comes back. If it comes back then that might be the next step, although I'm a bit more personally inclined to simply flap and debride which might definitively eliminate the etiology even though we me never find out what it really was. A biopsy submission would be possible with the flap procedure which would be very simple to perform. The enostosis idea is another good intellectual stab at what this might be. I liked Tinnin's retained primary root idea except it just happened to be the wrong area! It's fun to try and figure these out. Once in a while amidst our constant daily routine of endo after endo we get thrown a few curve balls. My point in presenting this one is to show that not every case presentation has an obvious answer. Quite frankly I still don't know what the Hell this is and won't pretend that I do. It's food for thought. Maybe some clever person will figure it out. If the sinus tract heals and never comes back, we'll never have a definitive answer to this puzzle. That's a good thing for the patient, but ironically not a good thing for our intellectual curiosity and educational growth. I'll keep you posted if I get more information with an update. Thanks again for your engagement and participation on the PDL site. I appreciate your support Ashley!

Ashley Mark commented 8 years ago.

A great friend of mine in my residency is an OMF radiologist. If it's ok with you, I will send him some images and get his thoughts. A

Terrell Pannkuk commented 8 years ago.

sure!

Kendel Garretson commented 7 years ago.

Any further development here? Sinus tract resolve? I agree with comment above that noted the entity appears to have PDL space. Possible retained primary root, unrelated to occurrence of fistula. Which of course begs the question -why the fistula? Interesting Thanks

Terrell Pannkuk commented 7 years ago.

The patient never came back and I got no follow-up report. Thanks for the prompting! I'll email the referring dentist and find out what the current status is.

Sam Cox commented 1 year ago.

So curious to know if you came to a verdict on this one - for the sake of my intellectual curiosity - but most hopeful that it resolved, for the patient’s sake.

Terrell Pannkuk commented 11 months ago.

Patient never came back! I wanted to learn from that one!

You must log in or create a free account to post a comment.

Related Cases

Heroic Retreatment of a Retreatment: Puzzle Case Part 2 Instructional, Complications: Advanced Management, Fractured Roots, Retreatment Strategies, Dismantling, Gutta Percha Removal, Recall Observations
Recall (5 Years): Radix Entomolaris Instructional, Cleaning and Shaping, Complications: Advanced Management, Recall Observations
Comparing Carrier Obturation versus Traditional RCT: Side by Side Clinical Endodontic Technique Instruction, Obturation
Clinical Concept: The Meaning and Purpose of Root Canal System Obturation Clinical Endodontic Technique Instruction, Obturation
Management and Follow-Up of the Combined Perio-Endo Lesion Instructional, Complications: Advanced Management, Endo-Perio Combined Lesions, Retreatment Strategies, Dismantling, Recall Observations
Complex Anatomy-Fused DB-P and MB-P Roots Instructional, Cleaning and Shaping, Obturation